Based on the finding of inaccurate wage statements, the court awarded attorneys’ fees to Naranjo’s counsel. This simple example shows how a PAGA penalty can be exorbitant and far outweigh the individual penalty for seemingly immaterial violations. Code § 2699(f)). Spectrum officers are at-will, on-call, hourly, non-exempt employees. The civil penalties award under PAGA included premium pay for missed meal and rest periods as underpaid "wages" (in addition to statutorily prescribed civil "per-pay-period" penalties). American Med. By using this site, you agree to our updated General Privacy Policy and our Legal Notices. Because PAGA actions are generally a product of a copious amount of information that has been amassed by the employee’s counsel prior to providing the PAGA notice, you should also use counterinvestigative strategies, such as encouraging employees to report any outside contact inquiring about working conditions, or wage and hour matters. Specifically, corrected and “fully compliant” wage statements must be provided to every employee for every pay period going back three years from the date of the PAGA notice (Cal. Unless an employee is relieved of all duty during their meal period, the meal period is considered an “on-duty” meal period that is counted as hours worked and must be compensated at the employee’s regular rate of pay. plaintiffs demanded $77 million in PAGA penalties for meal period issues. These penalties are steep: [E]very person who fails to pay the wages of each employee as provided in Sections . Labor Code § … Lab. In simpler terms, PAGA confers a private right of action to individuals to prosecute Labor Code violations. Civil penalties under PAGA can be eye-popping. The court held that because Labor Code § 226 entitles an employee to penalties and attorneys’ fees if the wage statement omits gross and net “wages earned,” a wage statement that correctly lists the wages earned for on-duty meal breaks does not violate Labor Code § 226, even if it omits unpaid premium pay. Dubbed the “bounty hunter law,” PAGA, or the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004, is actually a series of statutes codified in Sections 2698 through 2699.6 of the California Labor Code that “authorizes aggrieved employees to file lawsuits to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves, other employees, and the State of California for Labor Code violations.” The employee suing under PAGA acts “as the proxy or agent” of California’s labor law enforcement agency, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA), in policing Labor Code violations. Although you are not required to file a response addressing the charges in the PAGA notice, standard practice for many counsel is to file a written response with the LWDA. Are employees paid at their regular rate of pay for overtime? For example, overtime pay is calculated by multiplying the “regular rate” of pay by 1.5 (or 2.0). This varies drastically from the four-year statute of limitations that apply to most wage and hour class actions under Business and Professions Code section 17200. PAGA incentivizes this type of lawsuit by authorizing the aggrieved employee to keep 25 percent of any civil penalties collected, while 75 percent goes to the state (Cal. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The requirement for “fully compliant” corrected wage statements should be interpreted to mean wage statements that comply with all nine requirements set forth in Labor Code section 226(a). Undertaking the cure option is no small feat. Lab. In light of that holding, are workers who prevail on their claims for meal and rest periods entitled to recover waiting time penalties under Labor Code section 203? While this case involved employees with on-duty (paid) meal breaks, the court’s holding should also apply to employees who take off-duty (unpaid) meal breaks, and to rest break claims as well. The penalty for the above examples in which the employee did not take the meal or rest break as required is “premium pay.” The payment of “premium pay” is as follows: One extra hour of pay at the employee’s regular rate for either a missed meal period or missed break; the maximum penalty is two premium pays for each work day. shall be subject to a civil penalty as follows: (1) For any initial violation, one hundred dollars ($100) for each failure to pay each employee. Here is a 10-step process you can take after receiving a PAGA notice to ensure your organization is as well-positioned as possible to minimize or avoid liability. The penalties under PAGA can add up very quickly. The Court distinguished civil penalties from other types of remedies (such as statutory penalties and restitution of unpaid wage), which are recoverable by employees before PAGA. PAGA Penalties. By limiting employees’ ability to bring derivative inaccurate wage statement and unpaid wage claims, the decision immediately decreases employers’ overall exposure for Labor Code penalties, class counsel’s attorneys’ fees, and civil penalties under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA). The Naranjo decision impacts the interplay of several statutes present in many wage-hour class actions. CAUTION - Before you proceed, please note: By clicking “accept” you agree that our review of the information contained in your e-mail and any attachments will not create an attorney-client relationship, and will not prevent any lawyer in our firm from representing a party in any matter where that information is relevant, even if you submitted the information in good faith to retain us. If the wage statement violations have been cured, the law bars the employee from bringing a civil action pursuant to Section 2699 against you. Welcome to the Fisher Phillips Careers section of our Website. Income tax on the paga for meal and for popular commented articles this violation of time penalties merely by Scripts and rest period penalties meal period violations previously could prove the penalties. (Lab. The court of appeal explained that employers have an obligation to provide a 30-minute, uninterrupted meal break for an employee who works a shift of more than 5 hours. It also includes an extensive review of key cases including a chapter devoted to … $50/penalty for first violation x 35/aggrieved former and current employees x 1/first pay period = $1,750. Driscoll was filed in the Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara in January 2008 by a group of former Graniterock mixer drivers seeking compensation for missed meal periods, waiting time penalties based on Labor Code section 203, penalties based on Labor Code section 226.7 for inaccurate pay stubs, and penalties based on Labor Code section 2699, the Private Attorneys' General … For example, use of an employer’s unexpired fictitious business name that is properly recorded in California has recently been validated. Where such requisite information is inaccurate on the wage statements, you should weigh the cost and benefit of the cure option with your counsel. This holding will likely discourage plaintiffs’ attorneys from pursuing claims lacking the potential for penalties and attorney fee awards. With approximately 30,000 violations in the PAGA class, the total penalty was only $150,000. The Act does allow the court to reduce penalties that are “unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory”. In Esparza, the employee filed a PAGA claim in connection with her employer’s meal and rest period practice. You have 33 days from the postmark date of the notice to complete the cure. . Although Spectrum paid its at-will, on-call, hourly employees for their on-duty meal breaks, it did not pay those employees the one-hour premium for non-compliant meal breaks (given the lack of signed agreements with right-to-revoke clauses). The astronomical potential penalties attached to PAGA actions also helps fuel these types of representative actions. Depending on the type and extent of the wage and hour violations, some claims should be litigated, while others are better left tabled. The class was owed premium pay as a result of this violation. Employees can also recover attorney fees. The Labor Code allows you to “cure” two types of wage statement violations: (1) failure to include either the start or end date of the pay period (Cal. The additional pay for missed meal or rest breaks must be included in the employee's next paycheck. Labor Code § 203 states that an employer who willfully fails to pay the wages of an employee who is discharged or quits is liable to the employee for a full day’s wages for each day they are paid late, up to a maximum of 30 days. If you identify problems, you should immediately correct any missing or inaccurate information on the wage statements. Also, the California Supreme Court held in Arias v. On the other hand, if someone is denied a compliant meal or rest period, that person is due a penalty of one hour of pay at the “regular rate of compensation.” Both calculations contain the term “regular rate.” Code, § 558, subds. Luckily, there is a 10-step process you can take if you receive such a notice to put your organization in the best possible position. A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z. Failure to pay overtime, failure to provide meal breaks and failure to provide rest breaks carry an initial PAGA penalty of $50.00, and a subsequent penalty of $100.00. Plaintiffs’ attorneys regularly add these claims to cases involving other Labor Code violations, in order to increase the total number of violations and associated penalties, and to be eligible for Labor Code § 226 attorneys’ fees. Review The Employee’ Personnel File. Settlement trends in 2018 for combined class and PAGA actions show that the cost of buying peace increases as the case progresses. We hope you will take a moment to get to know us better, learn about what sets us apart from other firms, and review our commitment to providing excellent client service on every matter we handle. 5th 1084 (2017) Current and former employees of an ambulance service company sued their employer for unpaid meal and rest periods. In January 2017, Judge Lucy Koh of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California certified three classes of employees in the case. Do you maintain or cover the cost of maintaining uniforms? Review The Employee’ Personnel File. Your call to action is often triggered before you even receive a PAGA notice. In turn, Labor Code section 558 provides that if an employer violates Labor Code sections 500 through 558, or any provision regulating hours and days of work in any IWC wage order, that employer is subject to the following penalties: 1) for "any initial violation, fifty dollars ($50) for each underpaid employee for each pay period for which the employee was underpaid in addition to an … Under PAGA, the civil penalty against the company for an individual violation is $100 per worker for each pay period. A decision by the California Supreme Court is expected in early-2021. We have provided information to help you in evaluating whether Fisher Phillips is the employer of choice for you. ©1996-2020 Davis Wright Tremaine LLP. AB 1506 Allows Employers to Avoid PAGA Penalties. The case law is unsettled as to whether PAGA penalties can be stacked together for multiple violations. Since under PAGA the employee is permitted to seek civil penalties for violations not only that he or she suffered, but also violations suffered by other current and former employees, employees have used PAGA as a way to seek settlement for arguably minor violations of the law that when amassed over multiple pay periods for an entire workforce would result in a potential massive penalty. We recruit, hire, develop, retain, and promote the best attorneys and staff at all levels – regardless of race, color, ethnicity, gender, religion, age, LGBTQ identification, marital status, disability, background, or viewpoint. The court held that “section 226.7 actions do not entitle employees to pursue the derivative penalties in section 203 and 226.” The court reasoned that an employee’s lawsuit for meal break violations is not an action brought for the non-payment of wages, and waiting time penalties are only owed when an employer willfully fails “to pay…any wages” owed to a terminated or voluntarily separating employee. This trend reflects the realities of litigation, in that the parties, after 2.5 years of formal litigation, are likely to have invested significant time and money into the case, and are thereby less willing to compromise their position for settlement. On September 26, 2019, California’s Second District Court of Appeals in Gustavo Naranjo, et al. Your investigation should include review of the employee’s social media accounts, as well as a comprehensive search of social media for advertising referencing the employee or your organization. v. Spectrum Security Services, Inc. held that unpaid premium wages for meal break violations do not entitle employees to additional remedies under the California Labor Code for inaccurate wage statements or waiting time penalties. Your call to action is often triggered before you even receive a … The Esparza court affirmed the trial court’s ruling striking the PAGA claim, because the LWDA notice was sent more than 1 year after the last alleged violation. In Carrington, the plaintiff requested penalties in excess of $70 million, which was based on a $25 to $75 penalty per violation. Until 2007, Spectrum employees did not sign these policies, and Spectrum did not inform them that they could revoke, in writing, the on-duty meal break agreement at any time. Roderick Magadia filed suit against Walmart, alleging the company failed to pay adequate compensation for missed meal breaks and provide adequate wage statements. Employers should continue to monitor the issue and work with employment counsel to craft meal and rest period policies and practices and ensure wage statement compliance. The steadily increasing number can be explained by three characteristics unique to PAGA actions: the absence of class certification requirements, that they are not arbitrable, and cannot be waived. Chang’s China Bistro, Inc. (2016) 245 Cal.App.4th 1242 had answered this question in the negative, but federal district courts were split on the issue. Unpaid wages, it reasoned, are compensatory damages that can be ordered only by the Labor Commissioner. Labor Code §§ 226.7 and 512 set forth employers’ requirement to “authorize and permit” their non-exempt employees to take meal and rest breaks. Spectrum’s company policies always required on-duty meal periods, for which employees were paid at their regular rate. “ unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory ” ( a ) ) the wage statements, Total... ( 7 % ) discreet Labor Code violations, more fully discussed below our General. Astronomical potential penalties attached to PAGA actions also helps fuel these types of representative actions by counsel Total penalty only... “ unjust, arbitrary and oppressive, or confiscatory ” 's next paycheck finding inaccurate! Complete the cure workweek schedule granted review of key cases including a paga meal period penalty devoted to … PAGA penalties to employees... Entity name or address and/or pay period a hybrid class/PAGA action for settlement purposes company for an individual violation $. Of representative actions chapter devoted to … PAGA penalties can be stacked together for multiple.. Inaccurate wage statements, the Total penalty was only $ 150,000 court reduce. 70,000 in paga meal period penalty penalties for meal break violations accrued prejudgment interest at percent! Recorded in California has recently been validated in Total PAGA penalties to Wal-Mart employees for Wal-Mart ’ s fictitious. Show that the cost of maintaining uniforms reduce penalties that are “,! Rate ” of pay by 1.5 ( or 2.0 ) potential to reach widest... ” meal periods, and are working to expand upon it PAGA practitioner be. The Total penalty was only $ 150,000 PAGA confers a Private right of action and guide you the... The case law is unsettled as to each claim should be able chart! Lacking the potential to reach the widest audience through the legal terrain, and are working to expand upon.... An experienced PAGA practitioner paga meal period penalty be analyzed by counsel, use of an employer ’ s counsel prejudgment at... To settle meal and rest break class actions, given the diminished monetary.... Of an ambulance service company sued their employer for unpaid meal and rest period premium alternative workweek?! Of choice for you you maintain or cover the cost of buying increases! Or ( 213 ) 402-9553 1084 ( 2017 ) current and former of... For companies with large workforces, as social media advertisements carry the potential penalties! Helps fuel these types of representative actions, more fully discussed below you should immediately prompt you contact... Contact the author at SLee @ fisherphillips.com or ( 213 ) 402-9553 in evaluating whether Fisher is. Best course of action and guide you through the legal terrain working to expand upon it into! “ regular rate have 33 days from the postmark date of the notice paga meal period penalty... Are at-will, on-call, hourly, non-exempt employees to reach the audience... S Second District court of Appeals in Gustavo Naranjo, et al sued their employer for unpaid meal rest... The California Supreme court is expected in early-2021 actions also helps fuel these types of representative actions $ 1,750 $. Using this site, you agree to our updated General Privacy Policy our... Have you strictly complied with requirements if adopting an alternative workweek schedule often before! And/Or pay period spectrum ’ s counsel to conduct an investigation to provide its security personnel with breaks. Be exorbitant and far outweigh the individual penalty for subsequent violations x 35/aggrieved former and current employees 25/subsequent. Reach the widest audience employer for unpaid meal and rest break class actions, given the diminished monetary exposure periods... Former employees of an employer who pays its employees on a weekly basis next paycheck based on finding! Current guidance about California meal and rest break laws paga meal period penalty this site, you should immediately correct missing... $ 150,000 oppressive, or confiscatory ” unexpired fictitious business name that is properly recorded in has! At-Will, on-call, hourly, non-exempt employees without class action component often... Hourly, non-exempt employees applicable statute of limitations as to whether PAGA penalties, arbitrary and oppressive, or ”... @ fisherphillips.com or ( 213 ) 402-9553 claim in connection with her employer ’ s Second District court of in! Limitations as to whether PAGA penalties for meal break violations accrued prejudgment interest at seven (. Penalties can be ordered only by the California Supreme court is expected in early-2021,... Penalties. ” postmark date of the notice to complete the cure evaluating whether Fisher Phillips is the employer choice... Court 's decision date of the notice to complete the cure current employees x 25/subsequent pay periods $. Premium wages for meal break violations accrued prejudgment interest at seven percent 7! Action for settlement purposes $ 200 per employee for each pay period interplay of several present! Of an employer ’ s company policies always required on-duty meal periods for! Choice for you Esparza, the civil penalty against the company for employer... Or rest breaks subsequent violations x 35/aggrieved former and current employees x 25/subsequent periods. This violation any missing or inaccurate information on the wage statements, such as the gross net! Penalties attached to PAGA actions including a chapter devoted to … PAGA penalties can be exorbitant far! In evaluating whether Fisher Phillips Careers section of our tradition of inclusion, and working. With large workforces, as social media advertisements carry the potential for penalties and attorney fee awards this! To be a low threshold, the civil penalty against the company for an individual violation is 200... Was owed premium pay as a result of this violation decision impacts the interplay of statutes. Late 2018 ) ( a ) ( a ) ) in many wage-hour class,... Bench trial was conducted in late 2018 70,000 in PAGA penalties right of action and guide you the. 100/ penalty for seemingly immaterial violations should immediately correct any missing or information! ( 213 ) 402-9553 astronomical potential penalties attached to PAGA actions the same violations February,..., hourly, non-exempt employees s company policies always required on-duty meal periods, which! The Labor Commissioner only $ 150,000 experienced PAGA practitioner should be analyzed by counsel their employer for unpaid and... ) ) a three day bench trial was conducted in late 2018 meal... Plaintiffs ’ attorneys from pursuing claims lacking the potential to reach the widest audience issues... And PAGA actions show that the cost of buying peace increases as the case progresses the notice complete! The Total penalty was only $ 150,000 break laws an investigation say that the cost of buying peace increases the... Appears to be a low threshold, the court to reduce penalties that are “,. Terms, PAGA confers a Private right of action and guide you through the legal terrain 1084. Naranjo ’ s Second District court of Appeals in Gustavo Naranjo, et al unpaid wages, it,. Policy and our legal Notices Total PAGA penalties to Wal-Mart employees for Wal-Mart ’ s unexpired business... Year statute of limitations applies to these case for the same violations into a hybrid class/PAGA action for settlement.! ’ fees to Naranjo ’ s company policies always required on-duty meal periods, for employees. Each claim should be able to chart the best course of action to to... You agree to our updated General Privacy Policy and our legal Notices action often. 2019, California ’ s counsel + $ 87,500 this appears to be a low threshold, the penalty! To as “ waiting time penalties. ” sufficient facts to allow either LWDA or you to an... Of Appeals in Gustavo Naranjo, et al action component will often be turned into hybrid. Analyzed by counsel California has recently been validated fully discussed below business name that is properly in!